Investor Update
2185 On Wisconsin · Grafton, WI
Contact investor@matterdevelops.com if you need access.
Matter Development
Investor Update · Townhome Lease Up

2185 On Wisconsin
Townhomes

2185 Wisconsin Ave  ·  Grafton, WI  ·  Quarter III 2026

100%
Current Occupancy (18 of 18 Units)
Aug 2023
Construction Completed
$7.08M
Total Development Cost
2185 On Wisconsin Townhomes — Exterior
Scroll to explore
Asset Overview

A suburban infill townhome redevelopment at the gateway to the Village of Grafton, Wisconsin.

2185 On Wisconsin — Front Porches
Front Porches
2185 On Wisconsin — Garages
Garages
2185 On Wisconsin — Lower Level
Lower Level — Office, Den & Workout Space
Community
2185 on Wisconsin Townhomes18 Townhomes / 33,900 SF Gross incl. Garages — 2 BR + Den, 2.5 Bath
Location
2185 Wisconsin Ave, Grafton, WI ↗ Suburban infill redevelopment; gateway to the Village's commercial district
Total Units
18 Units3 townhome buildings, six connected units with 1.5 car garages each
Construction Completed
August 2023Approx. 2.8 years since completion as of Quarter III 2026
Ownership & Management
Matter Developmentmatterdevelops.com ↗Sponsor & developerSelf-managed by Matter DevelopmentAsset Management: Eric PillardLeasing Associate: Rachael Riedijk
Balance Sheet Summary
$7,077,833Total development cost$5,527,770Citizens Bank; fixed 7.09%; loan has entered amortization; matures 4/15/29
Current Operations

Fully leased at 100% occupancy with rents moving higher.

Current Occupancy
100%
All 18 units occupied per the current rent roll — up from 15 of 18 (83%) at the end of Q2.
↑ From 83% at End of Q2
Lease-Up Progress18 of 18 units · 100.0%
Average In-Place Rent
$2,462
Average net rent (after concessions) across the 18 occupied units on the 10/31 rent roll, up from $2,356 at the end of the prior quarter.
↑ From $2,356 Prior Quarter
Average Occupancy & Average Net Rent by Quarter — Q1 2024 to Q3 2026
Average occupancy (left axis) Average net rent per leased unit (right axis)
Average occupancy and average net rent by quarter, Q1 2024 to Q3 2026 Bars show each quarter's average occupancy, rising from 48% in Q1 2024 to 89% in Q3 2026, and 100% on the latest October 2026 roll. The line shows average net rent per leased unit, ending at $2,462 on the latest roll. 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% $1,900 $2,100 $2,300 $2,500 $2,700 Q1 2024: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 8, 8, 10 of 18. Average occupancy 48%, average net rent $2,582 48% Q1 ’24 8.7/18 Q2 2024: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 10, 11, 11 of 18. Average occupancy 59%, average net rent $2,398 59% Q2 ’24 10.7/18 Q3 2024: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 15, 15, 13 of 18. Average occupancy 80%, average net rent $2,384 80% Q3 ’24 14.3/18 Q4 2024: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 12, 12, 11 of 18. Average occupancy 65%, average net rent $2,382 65% Q4 ’24 11.7/18 Q1 2025: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 11, 10, 11 of 18. Average occupancy 59%, average net rent $2,393 59% Q1 ’25 10.7/18 Q2 2025: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 11, 11, 15 of 18. Average occupancy 68%, average net rent $2,315 68% Q2 ’25 12.3/18 Q3 2025: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 14, 14, 14 of 18. Average occupancy 78%, average net rent $2,383 78% Q3 ’25 14/18 Q4 2025: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 14, 14, 14 of 18. Average occupancy 78%, average net rent $2,350 78% Q4 ’25 14/18 Q1 2026: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 15, 16, 17 of 18. Average occupancy 89%, average net rent $2,399 89% Q1 ’26 16/18 Q2 2026: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 17, 17, 14 of 18. Average occupancy 89%, average net rent $2,360 89% Q2 ’26 16/18 Q3 2026: average of three monthly rolls. Leased units by month: 15, 15, 18 of 18. Average occupancy 89%, average net rent $2,312 89% Q3 ’26 16/18 October 2026 (latest roll): 18 of 18 leased (100%), average net rent $2,462 100% Oct ’26 18/18 $2,582 $2,398 $2,384 $2,382 $2,393 $2,315 $2,383 $2,350 $2,399 $2,360 $2,312 $2,462
Source: monthly rent rolls. Each quarter shows the average of its three monthly rolls; the final point is the latest October 2026 roll. Occupancy is leased units out of 18 as of each roll date, excluding future-dated leases not yet started, vacancies, and the model unit (leased in September 2026). Average net rent is total net rent (after concessions) divided by leased units and includes prorated first-month rents. Hover over a bar for the monthly detail.
Financial Performance

We have achieved strong occupancy, but interest costs have absorbed the cash flow.

2185 on Wisconsin is now fully leased and operating close to our original plan: occupancy is 100% against the 96% we underwrote, in-place rents are within 2% of plan, and year-to-date expenses are within 5% of plan. The challenge is financing. The loan’s fixed 7.09% rate is about 300 basis points above what we planned in 2022, and debt service has absorbed all of the cash flow, so we have not made a distribution since inception.

Current performance and underwriting comparison
 Next 3 monthsOct to Dec 2026, expected at stable occupancyInvestment proformaThree months of 2026Broker underwritingOne quarter, as-is, 5% vacancy
Total income$136,969$148,564$136,083
Operating expenses$41,254$38,430$36,820
Net operating income (NOI)$95,715$110,134$99,263
The next three months assume the October 31 rent roll (18 of 18 leased), with the two leases ending October 31 replaced at $2,695 (the second after a one-week vacancy), no vacancy allowance, real estate taxes of $5,292 a month, a 5% management fee, and other income and expenses at their 2026 run-rate. It is an estimate, not a guarantee, and does not include seasonal winter costs. Investment proforma is one quarter of the 2026 projection in the original investment overview. Broker underwriting is one quarter of the annual figures in a recent broker opinion of value (October 2026), which is not an appraisal, with income implied by the broker’s expense and NOI estimates.

At stable occupancy we expect NOI of about $96,000 over the next three months, or roughly $383,000 a year. That is within about 4% of the $397,000 an outside broker underwrites for the property as-is, and the broker sees $428,000 at market rents, so the property is earning close to what a stabilized asset like ours should.

The loan

The remaining gap is the loan. Annual debt service is $459,922, about $139,000 more than the $320,881 in our proforma. The balance is $5,527,770, and the loan matures in approximately 2.5 years (April 15, 2029). Matter has covered the shortfall through advances rather than asking investors for additional capital.

Next steps

With the property fully leased and operating close to plan, we are well positioned to explore our options. We plan to discuss the property with brokers to determine what options may be available (refinance, sale, etc.), and we will keep investors informed as we learn more.

Operations Highlights

Fully leased with momentum building, but new supply on the horizon.

◈ Occupancy & Rent
Positive

The community benefited from strong leasing activity from Port Washington Data Center staff. We ended October 100% occupied (18 of 18 units), up from 14 of 18 (78%) in June and 15 of 18 (83%) in July and August. September leases, including the former model unit, filled the remaining vacancies, and average net rent rose to $2,462 from $2,223 in August.

◈ Asset Management & Tenant Satisfaction
Positive

The property is self-managed by Matter Development. Associate Eric Pillard oversees tenant relations, work order requests and physical plant upkeep, and tenants have consistently described his service as responsive, helpful and empathetic. Leasing associate Rachael Riedijk handles leasing and tours.

◈ Lease-Up Challenges
Context

Lease-up took far longer than we underwrote. Average occupancy was 63% in 2024 and 71% in 2025, against 96% in our plan. We saw an opportunity and underwrote at a market low vacancy, with Southern Ozaukee County at 0.8% in early 2022 (per CoStar), but two things worked against us. Supply: four communities in CoStar’s comp set (833 units) delivered in 2024 and 2025 while we were leasing 18 homes, part of a record construction wave across metro Milwaukee. Amenities: competitors such as Fox Run in Cedarburg now offer a pool, fitness center and trails, and a property of our size cannot support shared space. On the positive side, occupancy reached 100% in September 2026, with strong demand from Port Washington Data Center staff.

See competitive set section below

◈ Competitive Supply
Monitoring

Two projects are coming to the Grafton area. The Farmstead on Falls (172 four-story apartment units, estimated May 2027) is under construction, with a two-bedroom asking rent of $2,732 per CoStar. Cirrus Property Group has also broken ground on The Carillon at Grafton: 34 build-to-rent triplex and quad units with private entrances, attached garages and fenced yards, targeting $1.80 to $2.30 per SF, with first residents potentially by spring 2027. The Carillon is the closer match to our product, and its target rents start at about our $1.80 per SF. Existing competitors include Seasons at Grafton and Fox Run, and the 17 comps in CoStar averaged 1.7% vacancy as of 8/6/2026.

◈ Leasing & Marketing
Gaining Traction

Units are advertised across Apartments.com, Zillow, Google Ads, signage and the property website, with prompt follow-up on leads and tour requests. Leasing picked up this year, with 11 move-ins through October, including four in September. Move-outs were 5 in 2024, 4 in 2025 and 7 through October 2026 (turnover rates of 28%, 22% and 39% respectively, of our 18 units), with six of this year’s seven move-outs coming in April and May as leases signed in 2025 expired. Renewal rates are average for the market; however, marketing time to secure a new lease exceeds the market average, largely due to the size of our property and the inventory availability in Grafton.

Market Position

Larger floor plans, priced in line with the Grafton market per square foot.

Avg. Asking Rent per Unit
$2,562
20% above CoStar’s $2,139 two-bedroom average; 2% above its $2,501 three-bedroom average
Avg. Unit Size
1,424 SF
Finished area, excluding garage; 29% larger than the 1,106 SF average across CoStar’s full 17-comp set. Three levels with 2 BR + den, 2.5 baths and an attached garage
Asking Rent per SF
$1.80
In line with CoStar’s $1.79 two-bedroom average and $1.85 across its full comp set
Two-Bedroom Asking Rent per Unit
Per month, 2185 on Wisconsin (2 BR + den, 2.5 bath) vs. 11 Grafton-area two-bedroom comps
Asking Rent per Square Foot
Per month, all unit types, vs. 11 Grafton-area comps
Farmstead on Falls† (2027 est.)
$2,732
$2.22
Seasons at Grafton (2025)
$2,653
$2.13
Arrabelle (2019)
$2,618
$2.04
2185 on Wisconsin (2023)TH
$2,562
$1.80
High Bluff Townhomes (2016)TH
$2,380
$1.69
Fox Run (2024)TH
$2,328
$1.70
Cedar Place Apartments (2019)
$2,170
$1.92
1505 Apartments (2017)TH
$2,092
$2.18
The Daniels (2024)
$1,955
$1.93
Hidden Hills Apartments (2022)
$1,817
$1.79
The Crossroad Commons (2024)
$1,783
$1.63
Hillside Estates (2014)
$1,730
$1.63
TH = townhome-style units. † Under construction (164 of 172 units listed as available; delivery estimated May 2027), so rents are pre-leasing asking rents. 2185 on Wisconsin is shown at its average asking rent on the 10/31/2026 rent roll ($2,495 on 12 units, $2,695 on 6 units). Our homes are a 2 BR + den, 2.5-bath townhome with an attached garage, so the two-bedroom comparison understates their size and amenities. Source: CoStar (comp set dated 8/6/2026), prepared by Colliers.
What This Means for 2185 on Wisconsin
Competitive Set

833 competing units arrived in 2024 and 2025, while we were leasing 18.

When we underwrote this project in early 2022, the timing looked right. CoStar showed Southern Ozaukee County multifamily vacancy at 2.2%, no units delivered in the prior 12 months, 109 units absorbed, and a forecast for vacancy to stay below 3% for at least three years. Then new supply arrived on a scale none of that data pointed to.

At underwriting · early 2022
2.2%
Submarket vacancy
0
Units delivered in the prior 12 months
109
Units absorbed in the prior 12 months
CoStar forecast vacancy to stay below 3% for at least three years.
CoStar later recorded a submarket vacancy low of 0.8% and a peak in rent growth of 8.8% in Q1 2022, the quarter we underwrote.
What followed · 2024 to 2025
833
Comp-set units delivered
18
Homes we were leasing
Our average occupancy was 63% in 2024 and 71% in 2025, against 96% in our underwriting.
Competing units delivered by year, CoStar comp set
Competing units delivered by year, 2019 to 2027 Stacked bars show units delivered by year. 553 units delivered in 2024 and 280 in 2025, a total of 833, while 2185 on Wisconsin delivered 18 units in August 2023 and leased up through September 2026. In 2027, The Farmstead on Falls (172 units) and The Carillon at Grafton (34 units) are under construction, 206 units in total. 833 units delivered, 2024–2025 2019 Arrabelle (2019): 69 units Arrabelle 69 Cedar Place Apartments (2019): 196 units Cedar Place 196 265 2020 2021 2022 Hidden Hills Apartments (2022): 70 units Hidden Hills 70 70 2023 2185 on Wisconsin (2023): 18 units 2024 The Daniels (2024): 215 units Daniels 215 Fox Run (2024): 230 units Fox Run 230 The Crossroad Commons (2024): 108 units Crossroad 108 553 2025 Seasons at Grafton (2025): 280 units Seasons 280 280 2026 2027 The Farmstead on Falls (est. 2027): 172 units Farmstead 172 The Carillon at Grafton (est. 2027): 34 units Carillon · 34 206 2185 on Wisconsin 18 units, Aug 2023 Our lease-up: Aug 2023 to Sep 2026 under construction est. 2027
Comp set by delivery date  ·  2024 and 2025 deliveries in bold
PropertyDeliveredUnits
The Farmstead on FallsMay 2027 (est.)172
The Carillon at Grafton2027 (est.)34
Seasons at Grafton2025280
The Daniels2024215
Fox Run TH2024230
The Crossroad Commons2024108
2185 on Wisconsin THAug 202318
PropertyDeliveredUnits
Hidden Hills Apartments202270
Arrabelle201969
Cedar Place Apartments2019196
1505 Apartments TH2017130
High Bluff Townhomes TH2016202
Hillside Estates201460
TH = townhome-style units. Source: CoStar rent comparables report (comp set dated 8/6/2026), prepared by Colliers. Delivered is CoStar’s year built; larger communities typically lease up over a year or more after delivery. The Farmstead on Falls is under construction. The Carillon at Grafton (Cirrus Property Group) is not in the CoStar report; its unit count and timing are from the Milwaukee Business Journal. Our lease-up window runs from completion in August 2023 to the first 100% occupancy on the 9/30/2026 rent roll. The 2022 market figures are from the project’s original investment overview, citing CoStar and CBRE.
Questions? Reach out directly.
Matter Development
2675 N Mayfair Road, Suite 200  ·  Wauwatosa, WI 53226
investor@matterdevelops.com
Matter Development
Managing Director & Founder
Aaron R. Matter
414-409-1295
aaron@matterdevelops.com