2185 Wisconsin Ave · Grafton, WI · Quarter III 2026
2185 on Wisconsin is now fully leased and operating close to our original plan: occupancy is 100% against the 96% we underwrote, in-place rents are within 2% of plan, and year-to-date expenses are within 5% of plan. The challenge is financing. The loan’s fixed 7.09% rate is about 300 basis points above what we planned in 2022, and debt service has absorbed all of the cash flow, so we have not made a distribution since inception.
| Next 3 monthsOct to Dec 2026, expected at stable occupancy | Investment proformaThree months of 2026 | Broker underwritingOne quarter, as-is, 5% vacancy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total income | $136,969 | $148,564 | $136,083 |
| Operating expenses | $41,254 | $38,430 | $36,820 |
| Net operating income (NOI) | $95,715 | $110,134 | $99,263 |
At stable occupancy we expect NOI of about $96,000 over the next three months, or roughly $383,000 a year. That is within about 4% of the $397,000 an outside broker underwrites for the property as-is, and the broker sees $428,000 at market rents, so the property is earning close to what a stabilized asset like ours should.
The remaining gap is the loan. Annual debt service is $459,922, about $139,000 more than the $320,881 in our proforma. The balance is $5,527,770, and the loan matures in approximately 2.5 years (April 15, 2029). Matter has covered the shortfall through advances rather than asking investors for additional capital.
With the property fully leased and operating close to plan, we are well positioned to explore our options. We plan to discuss the property with brokers to determine what options may be available (refinance, sale, etc.), and we will keep investors informed as we learn more.
The community benefited from strong leasing activity from Port Washington Data Center staff. We ended October 100% occupied (18 of 18 units), up from 14 of 18 (78%) in June and 15 of 18 (83%) in July and August. September leases, including the former model unit, filled the remaining vacancies, and average net rent rose to $2,462 from $2,223 in August.
The property is self-managed by Matter Development. Associate Eric Pillard oversees tenant relations, work order requests and physical plant upkeep, and tenants have consistently described his service as responsive, helpful and empathetic. Leasing associate Rachael Riedijk handles leasing and tours.
Lease-up took far longer than we underwrote. Average occupancy was 63% in 2024 and 71% in 2025, against 96% in our plan. We saw an opportunity and underwrote at a market low vacancy, with Southern Ozaukee County at 0.8% in early 2022 (per CoStar), but two things worked against us. Supply: four communities in CoStar’s comp set (833 units) delivered in 2024 and 2025 while we were leasing 18 homes, part of a record construction wave across metro Milwaukee. Amenities: competitors such as Fox Run in Cedarburg now offer a pool, fitness center and trails, and a property of our size cannot support shared space. On the positive side, occupancy reached 100% in September 2026, with strong demand from Port Washington Data Center staff.
Two projects are coming to the Grafton area. The Farmstead on Falls (172 four-story apartment units, estimated May 2027) is under construction, with a two-bedroom asking rent of $2,732 per CoStar. Cirrus Property Group has also broken ground on The Carillon at Grafton: 34 build-to-rent triplex and quad units with private entrances, attached garages and fenced yards, targeting $1.80 to $2.30 per SF, with first residents potentially by spring 2027. The Carillon is the closer match to our product, and its target rents start at about our $1.80 per SF. Existing competitors include Seasons at Grafton and Fox Run, and the 17 comps in CoStar averaged 1.7% vacancy as of 8/6/2026.
Units are advertised across Apartments.com, Zillow, Google Ads, signage and the property website, with prompt follow-up on leads and tour requests. Leasing picked up this year, with 11 move-ins through October, including four in September. Move-outs were 5 in 2024, 4 in 2025 and 7 through October 2026 (turnover rates of 28%, 22% and 39% respectively, of our 18 units), with six of this year’s seven move-outs coming in April and May as leases signed in 2025 expired. Renewal rates are average for the market; however, marketing time to secure a new lease exceeds the market average, largely due to the size of our property and the inventory availability in Grafton.
When we underwrote this project in early 2022, the timing looked right. CoStar showed Southern Ozaukee County multifamily vacancy at 2.2%, no units delivered in the prior 12 months, 109 units absorbed, and a forecast for vacancy to stay below 3% for at least three years. Then new supply arrived on a scale none of that data pointed to.
| Property | Delivered | Units |
|---|---|---|
| The Farmstead on Falls | May 2027 (est.) | 172 |
| The Carillon at Grafton | 2027 (est.) | 34 |
| Seasons at Grafton | 2025 | 280 |
| The Daniels | 2024 | 215 |
| Fox Run TH | 2024 | 230 |
| The Crossroad Commons | 2024 | 108 |
| 2185 on Wisconsin TH | Aug 2023 | 18 |
| Property | Delivered | Units |
|---|---|---|
| Hidden Hills Apartments | 2022 | 70 |
| Arrabelle | 2019 | 69 |
| Cedar Place Apartments | 2019 | 196 |
| 1505 Apartments TH | 2017 | 130 |
| High Bluff Townhomes TH | 2016 | 202 |
| Hillside Estates | 2014 | 60 |